Book an appointment with us, or search the directory to find the right lawyer for you directly through the app.
Find out more
The New Rules of Technology
This edition of Law Update looks at how technology is changing the legal questions businesses are facing across the region. From AI and deepfakes to cyber incidents, cloud services, data protection and digital assets, our lawyers examine where the risks are emerging and how regulators are responding.
The edition also brings together recent legislative developments and significant court decisions from across the UAE and Saudi Arabia, with a closer look at what they mean in practice for businesses operating in the region.
When a vessel approaches a busy port, the operation rarely depends on one person alone. A pilot climbs aboard to guide the ship in. Tugs are deployed to assist with speed and positioning. Yet despite this team effort, the question of who bears liability when damage occurs is not always straightforward. Understanding how liability is allocated between the vessel owner, pilot, and tug operator is therefore essential when assessing potential claims and rights of recovery.
Under The Commercial Maritime Law, pilotage at ports is mandatory for most commercial vessels. A licensed pilot must be on board whenever a vessel enters, exits, or moves within port limits. However, a critical legal principle applies: even while the pilot is actively guiding the vessel, the master remains in command.
This means the vessel’s operator (the owner is presumed to be the operator unless shown otherwise) carries liability for any damage that occurs during the pilotage, including damage to port infrastructure, other vessels, or third parties. The pilot and the body to which the pilot belongs are not liable for damage sustained by the vessel being piloted, and the operator is solely liable for damage caused to third parties by the pilot’s faults in the course of pilotage. The law places the financial risk squarely on the vessel’s operator.
So, if a vessel under pilotage strikes a jetty or damages a fender, the port authority’s claim will be directed at the vessel’s operator, not the pilot.
The Commercial Maritime Law does not grant the vessel owner or operator an express right of recourse against the pilot. On the contrary, it provides that the pilot and the body to which the pilot belongs are not liable for damage to the piloted vessel, and that the operator alone bears liability towards third parties for the pilot’s faults. The only reference to a pilot’s gross fault concerns a different situation: the operator is liable for damage sustained by the pilot boat during pilotage, or during the pilot’s embarkation or disembarkation, unless that damage arises from the pilot’s gross fault.
Any attempt to recover from the pilot would therefore have to rest on the general rules of liability rather than on a specific provision of the Commercial Maritime Law and would face the express statutory allocation of liability to the operator. The prospects of such a claim should be assessed with caution and will ultimately depend on the court’s assessment.
Importantly, the fact that pilotage is compulsory does not exempt the vessel from collision or allision liability. The law specifically provides that fault-based liability for collisions applies even where pilotage is mandatory.
Towage within ports follows a different but equally important principle: liability depends on who commands the operation.
By default, towage operations within port limits are carried out under the command of the towed vessel’s master. In that scenario, the towed vessel’s operator is liable for any damage that occurs during the towing, not the tug operator.
However, the parties may agree in writing to place the operation under the towing vessel’s master instead. If such an agreement exists, liability shifts to the tug operator, unless the damage is shown to be attributable to the towed vessel itself.
Beyond port limits, the default rule reverses: towage is presumed to be under the towing vessel’s command, and the tug operator bears liability, unless a written agreement says otherwise.
The law also addresses situations where the towing vessel itself causes damage to the vessel it is assisting. In such cases, the tug is generally liable, but it can avoid liability by proving the damage resulted from force majeure, an unforeseeable accident, a cause attributable to the towed vessel or an inherent defect in it, or a fault by the towed vessel’s operator, master, or crew.
This means that if tugs are underpowered, improperly equipped, or deployed too late during a critical maneuver, the vessel owner may have a basis for claiming against the tug operators. Evidence of equipment deficiencies or delays in making fast could support such a claim.
What happens when both the pilot’s error and the tugs’ deficiencies contribute to an incident? General legal principles allow liability to be apportioned where multiple parties contribute to harm, and the court can determine each party’s proportionate share of responsibility. However, the pilot’s position is governed by the specific allocation in the Commercial Maritime Law, under which the operator, not the pilot, bears liability for the pilot’s faults.
In practice, the vessel owner’s realistic path to recovery lies against the tug operators for equipment or operational failures, provided the evidence supports the claim and none of the statutory defences applies.
The Commercial Maritime law imposes strict limitation periods. Claims arising from pilotage or towage operations will not be heard after two years from the date the operation was completed.
Maritime incidents at port often involve a web of actors: the master, the pilot, the tug operators, each with defined roles and responsibilities under the law. The vessel operator sits at the center of liability, bearing primary responsibility even when compulsory pilotage and port tugs are involved, and bearing sole liability towards third parties for the pilot’s faults. The law preserves a right to claim against tug operators where the towing vessel causes damage and no statutory defence applies, while any claim against a pilot would depend on the general rules of liability. The strength of any claim depends on the evidence and, ultimately, the court’s assessment.
For vessel owners and their insurers, the practical lesson is to preserve all evidence from the moment an incident occurs and act within the applicable limitation period. The right to recover exists, but only where the claim can be supported by sufficient evidence.
For further information, please contact Ahmed Hashem, Partner and Head of Transport – KSA at a.hashem@tamimi.com or Jamal Natto, Associate, Transport & Insurance, Al Tamimi & Company, at j.natto@tamimi.com.