Force Majeure, Hardship and Stranded Cargo: Key Questions for Cargo Interests under UAE Law

time 4 min 33 sec

Disruption to the Strait of Hormuz, a major shipping corridor in the region, has left many cargo owners with stranded cargo at intermediate ports, voyages terminated mid-route and mounting detention, storage and surcharge invoices. In this article, we address the questions most frequently raised by carriers and cargo interests about the legal position under UAE law, including when a carrier may rely on force majeure provisions, how force majeure differs from unforeseen circumstances, who bears liability and how potential claims may be assessed by the UAE courts.

The general rule under Articles 175 and 185 of Federal Decree-Law No. 43 of 2023 Concerning the Maritime Law (the “Maritime Law”) is that the carrier is liable for cargo loss, damage or delay from receipt of the cargo until its safe delivery at the destination port, unless the carrier proves that it and/or its representatives took all necessary precautions to mitigate the damage.

Whether an event qualifies as force majeure is primarily determined by the terms of the relevant contract and, ultimately, by the court, which retains discretion to assess the circumstances of the dispute and determine whether performance of the contractual obligation has become impossible.

Force majeure and unforeseen circumstances

UAE law draws a clear distinction between force majeure, involving impossibility of performance, and unforeseen circumstances, involving hardship.

Under Article 236 of Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 Promulgating the Civil Transactions Law (the “CTL”), where performance of a contractual obligation becomes impossible due to force majeure, the corresponding obligation is extinguished, and the contract may be held to be terminated. For an event to qualify as force majeure, three essential elements must be satisfied:

  • Complete impossibility of performance.
  • Unavoidability.
  • Unforeseeability.

If non-performance does not satisfy all three elements, it should not be classified as force majeure.

By contrast, Article 224 of the CTL applies where performance is not impossible but would impose excessive hardship on the debtor, potentially resulting in substantial loss, or where performance is only partially impossible. In such cases, the court may, at its discretion, adjust the contractual obligations to restore fairness. It is generally accepted that, to qualify as an unforeseen circumstance, an event must:

  • Be exceptional and rare.
  • Be unavoidable, such that its consequences cannot be prevented through reasonable efforts.
  • Arise after the contract is concluded and before full performance.
  • Render performance significantly onerous, while remaining possible, resulting in substantial or unusual losses.

Under UAE law, hardship alone, where carriage remains possible but involves greater cost or a longer journey, does not constitute force majeure; impossibility must be established. Hardship is instead addressed under the unforeseen circumstances regime, where the remedy is judicial rebalancing of obligations rather than termination of the contract.

Where the closure of a key shipping route makes the contracted carriage difficult but not impossible, and judicial trends have not yet crystallised, there is a reasonable prospect that a UAE court would treat the situation as an unforeseen circumstance rather than a force majeure event. Nevertheless, the position should not be generalised, as the court will consider each case individually. The carrier will ordinarily rely on all contractual and legal rights, protections, exemptions, limitations and defences available under the applicable contract of carriage, laws and conventions.

Alternative discharge and additional charges

Article 147 of the Maritime Law and the general terms and conditions of carriage grant the carrier the right to deliver cargo to the nearest safe port where delivery to the agreed port is impossible.

Since ownership remains with the cargo interests, the carrier will generally be entitled to claim detention and storage charges from the date on which those charges begin to accrue under the contract of carriage and applicable tariffs. Cargo interests should check the bill of lading terms and tariffs carefully to identify the date on which charges start accruing.

Where a court accepts a carrier’s reliance on force majeure, it may order termination of the contract and permit the carrier to recover damages, costs, storage charges and/or demurrage associated with the cargo, even though the contracted voyage was not completed.

Where the court accepts a carrier’s reliance on hardship, it may decline to hold the carrier liable for delivery at a different discharge port and may allow recovery of reasonable storage charges, surcharges and accrued costs from cargo interests. Cargo interests should also be aware that terminal operators may incur storage charges that carriers subsequently seek to recover from them, together with destruction costs in cases involving abandoned containers.

The contract of carriage often grants the carrier broad powers to impose charges.

Abandoning deteriorating cargo

Where cargo has a limited shelf life and is deteriorating at an intermediate port, cargo interests may consider abandoning it. Although abandonment is theoretically possible, it carries risks. The carrier may still be entitled to recover costs incurred, including storage fees, damages and related expenses. Terminal charges and destruction costs may also follow.

Abandonment should therefore not be treated as a cost-free exit.

Transhipment and alternative routing

Transhipment through an intermediate port is generally within the carrier’s discretion unless expressly excluded. Cargo interests typically have no role in, or recourse against, that decision where the discretion is exercised reasonably.

Unless an express agreement prohibits transhipment or requires direct carriage, the carrier is entitled to route the cargo through intermediate ports or adopt a transhipment or multimodal approach without incurring additional liability. The voyage is considered to begin upon the carrier’s receipt of the cargo and to continue until delivery at the final port of discharge.

Abandonment should therefore not be treated as a cost‑free exit.

Allocating costs and mitigating losses

These circumstances raise the question of who bears the resulting costs. UAE law and the courts seek to balance the parties’ responsibilities, expecting them to act in good faith, perform their contractual obligations to the extent practicable or cooperate to bring the contract of carriage to an amicable end.

In practical terms, liability remains with the carrier until it invokes force majeure or unforeseen circumstances, supported by sufficient evidence that it took all necessary measures to mitigate the losses. All parties should act in good faith and seek to mitigate potential losses.

The situation is unprecedented, and a wide range of claims is expected. However, the assessment of one claim cannot be applied universally to others. Each claim must be assessed against the available documentation, the measures taken by the carrier to mitigate losses and the wider regional circumstances.

Federal and local courts in the UAE may adopt different approaches. Carriers and cargo interests should therefore make efforts to reach an amicable resolution of potential cargo claims.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Specific advice should be sought on particular circumstances.