Foreign Debtors, Local Assets: Enforcing Maritime Arbitral Awards in the UAE

time 3 min 38 sec

When considering how to enforce a maritime award, the debtor’s place of incorporation is only part of the picture. Its business interests elsewhere may also offer a means of recovery, including through the UAE’s onshore courts.

In a recent matter, Al Tamimi & Company obtained orders recognising and permitting enforcement of a foreign maritime arbitral award and its associated costs award after successfully challenging an initial refusal on jurisdictional grounds. The debtor was incorporated overseas, but official registration records showed that it wholly owned a UAE business registered as a sole establishment, however, operating under a different name .

The proceedings

The significant issue was that the award was issued against a foreign entity(debtor) and the local establishment was not named or mentioned in the award. The creditor’s initial petition was rejected for lack of territorial jurisdiction. On the documents before it, the court was not satisfied that the local establishment was a branch or management centre of the overseas debtor. The presented ownership evidence, according to the reasoning of the court, had therefore not established the jurisdictional connection relied upon in that application.

The creditor appealed, addressing the location of the debtor’s assets, the establishment’s registered legal form and its relationship with the debtor. The Court of Appeal exercised its discretion and issued inquiries from the relevant governmental authority to ascertain the ownership of the local establishment. The feedback received from the governmental authority was satisfactory to establish the relation between the foreign debtor and the local establishment. The appeal was allowed, the refusal was set aside, and recognition and enforcement of the principal and costs awards were ordered.

The creditor then pursued execution. An attachment restricted dealings with the debtor’s recorded ownership interest in the local establishment. Under a subsequent third-party attachment order, the establishment was required to disclose and transfer funds and profits which it held for, or owed to, the debtor, up to the amount being enforced.

The relevance of UAE assets

Recognition of a foreign award and execution against local assets involve related but distinct questions. The UAE is a party to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards 1958, which sets out the supporting documents required and the limited grounds for refusing recognition and enforcement. It does not allow the underlying dispute to be retried on its merits.

For the onshore courts, Articles 222 and 223 of Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2022 issuing the Civil Procedure Code, as amended, provide for an application to the execution judge. Article 225 preserves applicable treaties, so domestic procedure must be applied consistently with the Convention.

The location of the debtor’s assets is relevant to execution jurisdiction. Article 207(2) includes the court within whose district those assets are situated among the competent courts. A debtor’s overseas incorporation therefore does not end the enquiry into whether execution can be pursued in the UAE.

For the creditor, this means identifying the debtor’s local property and explaining its connection with the chosen court. Evidence that a foreign debtor has a commercial presence in the UAE may help, but the application must establish which ownership interests, funds or receivables actually belong to it.

Why the business’s legal form matters

Much depends on how the local business is constituted. Under the Commercial Companies Law issued by Federal Decree-Law No 32 of 2021, as amended, a registered company has its own distinct legal personality, including where a limited liability company has a single shareholder, as permitted by Article 71(2). A creditor enforcing against that shareholder cannot treat the company’s bank balances and other property as the shareholder’s own merely because the company is wholly owned.

A sole establishment stands in a different position. As the Federal Supreme Court has recognised, it has no legal personality separate from its owner. The applicable law and jurisprudence distinguish sole establishments owned by natural or legal persons from one-person limited liability companies. The execution remedy must still be assessed under the applicable law and the actual ownership records.

Commercial descriptions do not always reflect these distinctions. A business described as a ‘subsidiary’ or ‘group company’ in accounts or correspondence may have a different status in the licensing records. Licences, commercial register extracts and constitutional documents should therefore be read together, with any inconsistency clarified by the competent authority. This can make the difference between identifying an asset of the award debtor and seeking relief against property belonging to someone else.

A creditor enforcing against that shareholder cannot treat the company's bank balances and other property as the shareholder's own merely because the company is wholly owned.

From recognition to recovery

Once recognition has been obtained, the next steps depend on the property the creditor intends to pursue. An attachment of an ownership interest may prevent its transfer or restrict specified registry changes, according to the terms of the order. That can preserve the interest while execution continues, but further steps are needed to realise its value.

Where another person holds the debtor’s movable property or owes money to the debtor, third-party attachment, often called third-party garnishment, may be appropriate. Articles 252 onwards of the Civil Procedure Code govern that process. The distinction is important: an order requiring a third party to disclose and transfer the debtor’s funds does not amount to a general attachment of that third party’s own assets.

In practice, the creditor will need to confirm that the order has been served and implemented, review the third party’s declaration and pursue any further order required for payment. A restriction entered on the commercial register or an order for disclosure is a useful step, but it does not establish that funds have been recovered or that the award has been satisfied.

Implications for maritime creditors

For shipowners, charterers and other maritime creditors, the case is a reminder to investigate the debtor’s UAE interests before deciding where to enforce. That work should go beyond identifying a trading name or confirming that a business is wholly owned. Establishing the registered legal form and the debtor’s rights at the outset helps frame the application and assess whether the likely recovery justifies the cost of execution.