Recovering Port and Shipping Line Charges in Kuwait: A Case Study on the Burden of Proof

time 5 min 18 sec

Payment of a disputed shipping charge does not, by itself, establish a right to reimbursement. An importer seeking recovery must also demonstrate why the amount was not legally due.

That distinction was central to a Kuwaiti dispute in recent years concerning charges collected by a shipping line and its local agents upon the arrival of imported goods. The importer argued that freight had already been prepaid and that the destination charges duplicated amounts previously paid or lacked a legal basis. The claim ultimately failed because the evidence established payment, but not unlawful collection.

This article examines a particularly instructive case in which a specific importer pursued an ambitious and far-reaching litigation strategy, filing a series of lawsuits against virtually all shipping companies and maritime lines operating in Kuwait in an effort to recover the fees it had paid over time. The importer’s central contention was that the charges collected upon the arrival of its goods at port were duplicative of freight costs already prepaid before shipment and were therefore unjustified

The proceedings illustrate how Kuwaiti courts approach the burden of proof, expert evidence and the limits of cassation review. They also offer practical lessons for businesses challenging port and shipping line charges.

The dispute: prepaid freight and additional charges

In 2019, an importer (the “Claimant”) brought proceedings against a shipping line and its local agents (the “First Defendant”), together with the Ministry of Commerce and Industry (“MOCI”).

The Claimant challenged various charges collected when its goods arrived at Kuwaiti ports, including congestion charges and other handling and ancillary fees. It alleged that the charges had no proper legal or ministerial basis, did not correspond to services provided, or duplicated freight costs paid before shipment.

According to the Claimant, payment had been necessary to obtain release of the cargo. It sought the appointment of an expert to identify amounts collected without entitlement, reconcile the parties’ accounts and determine the sum recoverable. It also requested costs and actual legal fees.

The case formed part of a wider litigation strategy in which the importer pursued recovery claims against multiple shipping companies and maritime lines.

First instance: the claimant’s evidentiary burden

The First Defendant sought dismissal, relying on Article 1 of Kuwait’s Law of Evidence. That provision places the burden of proving an obligation on the creditor and the burden of proving discharge on the debtor. In this case, the Claimant sought to establish an obligation to reimburse the disputed payments.

The First Defendant argued that the Claimant had not produced adequate evidence supporting that obligation. It also maintained that the dispute arose from a contract of carriage by sea and was governed by the Maritime Commerce Law as the applicable special legislation.

The documents relied upon by the Claimant included its own statement of charges, invoices and a judgment referring an unrelated dispute to an expert. The First Defendant submitted that these materials did not demonstrate that the charges were unlawful or recoverable.

It further argued that appointing an expert was a matter for the court’s discretion, rather than a procedural entitlement available merely upon request.

The Court of First Instance rejected the application for an expert and dismissed the claim. Its central finding was that the Claimant had failed to establish that the disputed charges had been unlawfully imposed.

Appeal: expert investigation did not establish entitlement

The Claimant appealed, arguing that the judgment was inadequately reasoned and that refusing an expert appointment had impaired its right of defence. It maintained that its documents demonstrated payment without legal justification and that expert examination was necessary to resolve the dispute.

The Claimant repeated its allegation of duplicate charging: amounts paid before shipment had allegedly been imposed again on arrival for the same goods. It also alleged breaches of Kuwait Ports Authority (“KPA”) decisions.

The Court of Appeal admitted the appeal in form and appointed an expert committee before determining the merits.

The committee reviewed the documents, met the parties and considered their submissions. It also visited the KPA, MOCI and the General Administration of Customs to investigate the basis of the charges.

Its findings drew a decisive distinction. Payment vouchers confirmed that the Claimant had paid the disputed amounts. However, the investigation did not establish that those amounts had been collected unlawfully, without entitlement or in circumstances requiring reimbursement.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the first-instance judgment. It found that the charges related to services actually provided and that the Claimant had not proved that the destination charges were identical to amounts paid in advance.

The expert inquiries also failed to establish violations of the relevant authorities’ decisions, regulations or instructions. Consequently, the evidence did not demonstrate duplicate charging or another basis for recovery.

Cassation: disagreement with factual findings was insufficient

The Claimant challenged the appellate judgment before the Court of Cassation. It alleged errors of law, inadequate reasoning and inconsistency with the evidence.

Its arguments again focused on the absence of a legal basis for the charges, the alleged lack of corresponding services and the contention that prepaid freight prevented additional charges upon arrival. It also argued that the Court of Appeal had disregarded relevant documents and administrative decisions.

The matter was referred to the Public Prosecution before the Court of Cassation for its opinion. The Prosecution recommended admitting the appeal in form but rejecting it on the merits.

It considered that the Court of Appeal had properly applied the burden of proof and grounded its conclusions in the documents and expert findings. The Claimant had not established that:

  • Charges collected after arrival duplicated those paid before shipment.
  • The disputed amounts had been collected without entitlement.
  • The charges breached applicable KPA or Customs decisions or instructions.
  • Any disputed charge exceeded the applicable lawful rate.

The Prosecution also observed that the objections largely challenged the assessment of evidence and reliance on the expert report. These matters generally fall within the trial courts’ factual jurisdiction, rather than providing an opportunity to reopen the factual dispute on cassation.

The Court of Cassation subsequently declined to admit the appeal and disposed of it in chambers. It considered the lower courts’ reasoning sufficient to support the outcome and found no relevant legal error, deficiency in reasoning or contradiction with the evidence. It ordered the Claimant to bear the costs and forfeited the security deposit.

The dismissal of the recovery claim therefore remained undisturbed.

Written by
Ahmed Rezeik

Of Counsel - Head of Shipping - Kuwait (Consultant)

A.Rezeik@tamimi.com View LinkedIn Profile
The ultimate lesson is straightforward: proving that money changed hands is only the beginning. A successful recovery claim must establish why the recipient was not entitled to retain it.

Practical lessons for importers and shipping lines

The case does not establish that every destination charge is lawful. Its significance is that allegations of unlawful or duplicate charging require evidence directed to the particular amounts and services disputed.

For importers, a recovery claim should distinguish between the fact of payment and the legal basis for reimbursement. Invoices and payment vouchers may establish the former without proving the latter.

An allegation of duplication should identify the particular charge paid before shipment, the destination charge said to repeat it and the evidence linking both payments to the same service.

The description “freight prepaid” should be examined alongside the carriage terms and supporting documents, rather than treated as resolving every destination-charge question.

Where a claim relies on a regulatory breach, the relevant decision, tariff or instruction should be identified and connected to the disputed charge. The calculation should show how the amount collected departed from the applicable requirement.

Shipping lines and agents should likewise preserve records explaining the services provided, the contractual or regulatory basis for their charges and the amounts collected. Those records may become central to defending reimbursement claims.

The ultimate lesson is straightforward: proving that money changed hands is only the beginning. A successful recovery claim must establish why the recipient was not entitled to retain it.