Dubai Court of Appeal Reaffirms Strict Time Limits in Civil Appeal No. 1706 of 2026

time 6 min 56 sec
Written by
Ammar Haykal

Partner, Head of Office – Sharjah and Ras Al Khaimah

a.haykal@tamimi.com View LinkedIn Profile

Introduction

In Civil Appeal No. 1706 of 2026, decided on the 22 October 2026, the Dubai Court of Appeal ruled that a foreign company’s appeal was time-barred. The company had lost a judgment worth more than AED 143 million in its absence. The court did not decide the merits, the service challenges against the original claim, or the arbitration objection.

It held that the time to appeal had started once the company was validly served, by newspaper publication, with the execution instrument for the judgment.

The decision restates three practical principles. Giving notice of the execution instrument counts as giving notice of the judgment. A challenge to the validity of that notice must be raised clearly in the appeal statement itself. Appeal deadlines are a matter of public order, which the court applies on its own initiative. The decision is a warning to offshore parties that do not keep track of proceedings in the UAE.

Background

The dispute arose from a land transaction in Dubai. In 2006 the First Respondent, a Dubai developer, agreed to buy a plot in a waterfront project from the Second Respondent for AED 110,195,540, and paid AED 22,039,106 of the price. In 2007 the First Respondent entered into a premium agreement with the Appellant, a company registered in the British Virgin Islands.

Under it, the Appellant agreed to pay AED 89,609,560 in return for the First Respondent giving up its rights under the sale agreement and the Appellant taking its place. The Appellant also agreed to repay the AED 22,039,106 already paid towards the price.

A three-party agreement then cancelled the original sale agreement and substituted the Appellant as buyer. The amount payable was AED 111,648,666 in total, of which the Appellant paid AED 38,931,711, leaving AED 72,716,955 outstanding.

The First Respondent sued in 2022. It claimed the unpaid balance and contractual late-payment penalties of 1% per month under clause 3‑2. The Appellant did not appear, despite being served. After receiving expert reports, the Court of First Instance ordered the Appellant to pay AED 72,716,955 plus 5% interest from 27 July 2022. It also awarded AED 70,974,188.60 in late-payment penalties.

The First Respondent then opened execution proceedings for AED 147,413,861.85. The execution instrument and the demand for payment were served by publication in a newspaper on 3 October 2023. Later execution and attachment notices were also published. An attachment was placed on land registered in the Appellant’s name.

The Appellant filed its appeal electronically on 20 August 2026. It argued that service of both the claim and the judgment was invalid. It said it had been served by publication without adequate prior enquiries, through a telephone number that was not its own, even though its BVI address appeared in the contracts. In the alternative, it argued that the Dubai Courts had no jurisdiction because of an arbitration clause under the DIAC rules in the 2007 cancellation agreement.

The First Respondent argued that the appeal was out of time. It also said the Appellant had actual knowledge of the execution and attachment, because it had taken part in related proceedings before a compensation committee concerning the same land.

Only in a later reply memorandum did the Appellant challenge the validity of the execution instrument and the demand for payment.

The Court’s Findings

The court began with the procedural framework in Federal Decree‑Law No. 42 of 2022 (the Civil Procedure Law). Under Article 161, the time limit for an appeal is 30 days.

Under Article 153, time generally runs from the day after the judgment is issued. Where the losing party did not attend any hearing and filed no defence, time runs instead from service of the judgment on that party. Failing to meet the deadline means the right to appeal is lost, and the court must say so on its own initiative.

Article 10 sets the order of methods for serving companies. Service by publication or other alternative methods is available only where there is no place of management, the office is closed, or service is refused.

The court then applied Court of Cassation case law, citing Commercial Appeal No. 567 of 2026, decided on 21 May 2026.

That line of authority holds three things. First, a plea of nullity that does not concern public order, including a challenge to service of the judgment or the execution instrument, must be raised in the appeal statement, and the appeal court cannot consider it on its own initiative. Second, service of the execution instrument on the judgment debtor counts as service of the judgment itself. This applies whether service was effected by a court officer or by newspaper publication, provided the notice states what the judgment ordered. Third, an appellant that does not challenge service of the execution instrument expressly and decisively in its appeal statement loses the right to do so.

Applying these principles, the court reviewed the execution file. An attempt to serve the execution instrument on 18 September 2023 failed: no clear address could be found and calls to the company went unanswered.

On 1 October 2023 the First Respondent asked to serve by publication. In support, it explained that a search of the National Economic Register had found no record of the Appellant, which was based outside the UAE.

The execution judge allowed service by publication on 2 October 2023, and the instrument was published the following day. The court found that service by publication was valid, because it followed a failed attempt at the Appellant’s address and enquiries that confirmed the Appellant had no presence in the UAE.

Since the appeal statement did not challenge service of the execution instrument, the court held that the service was valid and effective. Time therefore ran from that service. With the judgment issued on 10 July 2023 and the appeal filed on 20 August 2026, the appeal was well outside the 30-day limit. The court described appeal deadlines as matters of public order that it applies on its own initiative.

The court also rejected the challenge to the execution instrument raised in the reply memorandum. This was a procedural plea that had to be included in the appeal statement with the Appellant’s other pleas, so the right to rely on it had been lost.

The court ruled that the right of appeal had lapsed because the appeal was filed out of time. It ordered the Appellant to pay costs and AED 1,000 in legal fees, and the appeal deposit was forfeited.

Significance of Judgment

The judgment makes clear how a defaulting party’s procedural defences interact with execution. The Appellant’s challenges to service of the original claim and of the judgment may or may not have had merit. The court never reached them, because an independent event had already started the appeal period: valid service of the execution instrument.

Under Article 153, where a party was absent throughout, time runs from service of the judgment.

Treating service of the execution instrument as service of the judgment means that a judgment creditor who moves promptly to execution can make the judgment final, even where the debtor says it never received the original claim.

The decision also shows how strictly the requirement to plead in the appeal statement is applied. The appeal statement concentrated on service of the claim and of the judgment. Raising the execution-instrument point later, in a reply memorandum, could not cure the omission. Practitioners should identify and challenge, in the appeal statement itself, every notice that could have started time running. That includes execution notices as well as service of the judgment.

On service by publication against foreign companies, the court accepted a sequence of an unsuccessful attempt at service, unanswered calls, and a search of the National Economic Register showing no UAE presence, followed by judicial permission to publish.

That was enough to make service valid. The Appellant’s point that its BVI address appeared in the contracts did not change the result. Because the challenge was not properly raised in the appeal statement, the court was not required to assess it. Offshore investors with assets or contracts in Dubai should note that publication in a local newspaper can bind them, and can start appeal periods running, without their actual knowledge.

Finally, the outcome confirms that once an appeal is held out of time, jurisdictional objections such as an arbitration clause are effectively lost. The Appellant’s DIAC arbitration argument was never considered. Under UAE practice, a party that wishes to rely on an arbitration agreement must generally raise it at the first opportunity before the court of first instance. A party that does not appear at all risks losing that protection entirely.

Written by
Ammar Haykal

Partner, Head of Office – Sharjah and Ras Al Khaimah

a.haykal@tamimi.com View LinkedIn Profile
Civil Appeal No. 1706 of 2026 is a reminder that procedural deadlines in Dubai are strict and applied as a matter of public order.

Conclusion

Civil Appeal No. 1706 of 2026 is a reminder that procedural deadlines in Dubai are strict and applied as a matter of public order.

By confirming that valid service of an execution instrument, including by publication, is service of the judgment, the Dubai Court of Appeal allowed a judgment of more than AED 143 million to become final.

The Appellant’s challenges to service and jurisdiction were never heard on the merits. For judgment creditors, the decision shows the value of prompt and properly documented execution steps. For foreign counterparties, the lesson is to keep a reliable address for service in the UAE, monitor proceedings and execution files actively, and act within 30 days of any notice that could start the appeal period. Any challenge to that notice must be raised expressly in the appeal statement itself.