Book an appointment with us, or search the directory to find the right lawyer for you directly through the app.
Find out more
The New Rules of Technology
This edition of Law Update looks at how technology is changing the legal questions businesses are facing across the region. From AI and deepfakes to cyber incidents, cloud services, data protection and digital assets, our lawyers examine where the risks are emerging and how regulators are responding.
The edition also brings together recent legislative developments and significant court decisions from across the UAE and Saudi Arabia, with a closer look at what they mean in practice for businesses operating in the region.
This article examines a Dubai Courts dispute concerning damage to pharmaceutical production equipment during handling in China before its intended maritime shipment to the UAE. The parties were a UAE pharmaceutical manufacturer purchasing the equipment (the “Claimant”) and a UAE free-zone freight and logistics provider whose activities included transport and customs clearance (the “First Defendant”). An overseas logistics operator’s Shanghai branch, engaged to perform transport operations in China, was brought into the proceedings as a joined party under an indemnity claim (the “Overseas Operator”). The equipment supplier was not a party to the proceedings. The litigation centred on whether the First Defendant had undertaken the inland transport operations, whether it was responsible for the Overseas Operator, and whether standard trading conditions limited its liability.
The courts awarded replacement costs for two damaged machines. The Court of Cassation upheld the outcome, addressing contractual scope, liability limits, and compensation.
The Claimant purchased an integrated pharmaceutical production line from a manufacturer in China on Ex Works terms (“EXW”) and engaged the First Defendant to arrange shipment from the factory in China to the Claimant’s warehouse in Dubai/Jabal Ali (door to door). The First Defendant’s licensed activities included freight, transport and customs clearance.
The shipment involved transport from China to the UAE. During handling on land, part of the equipment sustained significant damage. The Claimant sought damages against the First Defendant and others. The First Defendant disputed responsibility for the damaged container and challenged the nature and amount of the losses claimed.
The court appointed a committee of four experts. The committee submitted an original report and a supplementary report. Those reports, the parties’ correspondence and a technical report from the manufacturer became central to the courts’ findings.
The Claimant maintained that the First Defendant had undertaken transport from the manufacturer’s premises in China to Dubai, relying on the accepted quotation and correspondence. It also maintained that the First Defendant had engaged the Overseas Operator to perform the inland operations and was responsible for the negligence in handling that damaged the equipment.
It relied on manufacturer assessments supporting replacement of the two machines rather than repair. In addition to physical loss, it claimed transport and storage expenses, technical-assessment costs, lost profits arising from delayed production and damage to its reputation and market position.
The First Defendant advanced these principal positions:
Scope of engagement and standing: Its responsibilities began at the port of shipment, not at the manufacturer’s premises. It disputed any instruction concerning the damaged container, asserted that other containers had been delivered and paid for, and argued that the Claimant had independently arranged the disputed inland operations. It challenged the absence of a formal transport contract and proof of its receipt of the particular cargo.
Responsibility for the Overseas Operator: The First Defendant denied that the relevant handling occurred under its supervision or control. It also relied on an alleged acknowledgement by the Claimant that it was not responsible for the accident.
Force majeure and proof of fault: Its initial arguments questioned the evidence explaining the accident and invoked force majeure and maritime exemptions.
Contractual limitation: Alternatively, it relied on NAFL trading conditions and a limitation of liability of AED 30 per kilogram of net damaged cargo weight, capped at AED 20,000 per shipment or unit, whichever was lower, without conceding liability.
Quantum and expert evidence: It disputed total loss and requested further expert examination.
These were submissions, not accepted findings. The liability and limitation defences failed.
A) Court of First Instance
The court found that the First Defendant undertook transport, engaged the Overseas Operator for inland operations and failed to take necessary cargo-preservation precautions. It held the First Defendant responsible for subcontracted land transport, referring to Federal Decree-Law No. 50 of 2022, Promulgating the Commercial Transactions Law. The cited provisions are summarised below:
Article 272: Carriage provisions apply to associated operations unless those operations constitute the contract’s main objective.
Article 278: Carriers are not liable for damage from carriage disruption or route deviation necessary to assist sick, injured or endangered persons.
Article 291(1): Carriers must follow the agreed route or, absent agreement, the shortest route.
Article 294(1): While goods remain with the carrier, consignors may change carriage instructions, subject to freight, costs and compensation for resulting damage. Any issued bill-of-lading copy must be returned for signed amendments; otherwise, implementation may be refused.
Article 304(1): Carriers are not liable for natural, usual weight or volume loss unless another cause is proved.
Article 308: Liability limits for loss or damage must not be fictitious and remain subject to judicial scrutiny. No damages are payable if no loss occurred; agreed damages may be reduced to actual loss. Recovery cannot exceed the agreed limit unless the carrier or its subordinates committed fraud or gross fault, requiring full compensation.
The replacement costs of the two machines were proved, and the court ordered the First Defendant to pay those costs, together with 5% annual interest from the date the judgment became final, plus fees and expenses.
B) Court of Appeal
The Court of Appeal adopted the first-instance reasoning and accepted the committee’s reports concerning responsibility for the cargo damage and the replacement cost. Having been satisfied with the existing expert evidence, it found no reason to appoint another expert.
C) Court of Cassation
The Court of Cassation dismissed the First Defendant’s appeal, reasoning as follows:
Correspondence and expert reports established the First Defendant’s undertaking to transport the production line from the inland origin to Dubai, despite the absence of a single formal contract. Its communications identified the Overseas Operator as its agent and attributed the damage to that operator’s negligence.
Responsibility extended from receipt to delivery, including subcontracted operations, with delivery required in the condition in which the cargo was received and within the agreed time. The NAFL cap failed because it was not linked at all to this shipment.
Replacement costs were proven direct losses within the pleaded claim.
Technical evidence supported replacement of essential parts that could not practicably be repaired or reused.
The litigation underscores that a logistics provider’s responsibility turns on the scope of its proven undertakings and operational arrangements, rather than merely on the shipment’s maritime character, the location of the damage or the particular stage of the transport journey at which it occurred. Where those undertakings encompass the relevant leg of the shipment, the provider’s responsibility extends to performance through its subcontractors: subcontracting does not, of itself, relieve the provider of responsibility for loss or damage attributable to their acts or omissions. Nor is that responsibility displaced merely because the damage occurred outside the UAE or during a particular stage of the shipment journey. The critical question is whether the loss arose within the scope of the transport obligations assumed by the provider, subject to the applicable liability regime and any effective contractual exclusions or limitations.
The decisions contain no substantive ruling on customs classification, valuation or duties. For businesses combining freight and clearance services, the practical lesson is to define clearly the scope and duration of custody and transport obligations, including responsibility for subcontracted stages and overseas operations; establish that any trading conditions have been effectively incorporated; and preserve reliable records of instructions, subcontracting arrangements, handovers, incidents and losses.