Book an appointment with us, or search the directory to find the right lawyer for you directly through the app.
Find out more
The New Rules of Technology
This edition of Law Update looks at how technology is changing the legal questions businesses are facing across the region. From AI and deepfakes to cyber incidents, cloud services, data protection and digital assets, our lawyers examine where the risks are emerging and how regulators are responding.
The edition also brings together recent legislative developments and significant court decisions from across the UAE and Saudi Arabia, with a closer look at what they mean in practice for businesses operating in the region.
In a significant ruling for small and medium enterprises (SMEs) participating in public procurement in Kuwait, the Court of Appeal has upheld a first instance judgment annulling a Central Agency for Public Tenders (CAPT) award decision that had denied an SME bidder the 20% price preference under Article 62 bis of Law No. 49 of 2016 on Public Tenders (added by Law No. 74 of 2019). The courts (in Kuwait Court of Appeal (Third Administrative Circuit) Appeals Nos. 2192, 2209 and 2367/2026 dated Judgment 22 September 2026 rejected the administration’s position that the SME preference cannot apply to tenders for imported products that are not manufactured locally, holding that Article 62 bis is general, unqualified and independent of the local product preference in Article 62.
The judgment also offers useful guidance on standing in tender challenges after the contract has been signed, on the effect of a CAPT decision to defer a grievance on the time limit for bringing annulment proceedings, and on the proper defendant in such proceedings.
The dispute concerned a Ministry of Electricity and Water tender for the supply, installation and operation of a photovoltaic system on car park shades and buildings at the southern power stations. Fourteen bids were submitted. The Claimant, a company registered with the National Fund for SME Development, submitted a compliant bid of KD 1,763,872.
By Decision No. 70 of 7 May 2025, the CAPT Board awarded the tender to another contractor (the Awardee), the second-lowest bidder at KD 1,487,342, after the lowest bid was excluded as non-compliant. The Claimant’s bid was therefore approximately 18.6% above the Awardee’s, within the 20% margin set by Article 62 bis, which requires award to a compliant SME bid priced no more than 20% above the lowest accepted bid.
The Ministry had taken the view, citing instructions of the Fatwa and Legislation Department, that the SME price preference could not apply to tenders for imported products that are not manufactured locally, and that because the tender was predominantly a supply tender, the presence of SME bidders did not affect the ranking of bids. The Claimant’s grievance to the CAPT Grievances Committee was rejected on 24 June 2025, and it filed annulment proceedings on 31 July 2025, together with a claim for provisional compensation of KD 5,001. The contract was signed with the Awardee on 6 November 2025, with a 27-month performance period.
The Court of First Instance annulled Decision No. 70 with all consequences, chiefly the re-evaluation of the Claimant’s bid and recognition of its preference. It held that Article 62 bis is general and unqualified as to whether the supplied products are local or imported, that it stands independently of the local product preference in Article 62, and that the two regimes must not be conflated. It relied on the explanatory memorandum to Law No. 74 of 2019, which emphasised supporting SMEs and broadening the base of state contractors. It added that supply from abroad applied to all bids, and there was no evidence that the Awardee supplied or manufactured locally. The court rejected the objection that the Claimant had lost its interest because the contract had been signed: performance was in its early stages, so restoring the prior position remained practicable. It dismissed the compensation claim for lack of proof of damage, finding that annulment itself restored the position, and ordered summary enforcement without security.
The Court of Appeal dismissed all three appeals (by the Claimant, the administration and the Awardee) and adopted the first instance reasoning. It further held that: (i) the claim was inadmissible against the Prime Minister, as CAPT is a public body with independent legal personality; (ii) the claim was not time-barred, because CAPT’s decision of 5 February 2025 to defer the Claimant’s earlier grievance suspended the presumption of implied rejection, so the rejection only became certain with the award decision; (iii) the Claimant retained its interest, as only about three months of the contract had run when summary enforcement was ordered; and (iv) annulment of the award was sufficient redress, so the compensation appeal failed.
The judgment is an important confirmation that the SME price preference under Article 62 bis is a mandatory, stand-alone entitlement. Contracting authorities and CAPT cannot read into it a local-manufacture condition borrowed from Article 62, and cannot disapply it simply because a tender is predominantly for imported supplies. For SME bidders, the decision strengthens the basis for challenging awards that overlook the preference.
The ruling also shows that signing a contract does not of itself defeat a challenge where performance is at an early stage, and that courts may order summary enforcement to prevent the contractual position becoming irreversible. Awardees should factor this risk into early mobilisation. On the procedural side, a CAPT deferral of a grievance may postpone the running of time, and claims should be directed at CAPT rather than the Prime Minister. Finally, claimants seeking damages should be ready to particularise and evidence their loss, as annulment may otherwise be treated as sufficient redress.