As we witness the evolution of the regulatory landscape across the MENA region, it was timely for us to investigate and lift the lid, on what is keeping the region’s legal decision-makers awake at night.
Our first-of-its-kind report titled Legal Leaders in MENA is out now! It captures the views of 700 legal decision-makers across nine countries and 13 industry sectors in MENA, as well as in-depth interviews with experts from key sectors such as financial services and education to name a few, which revealed the emerging risks and priorities challenging the legal sector across the region.
Read the full report and share your feedback with us at firstname.lastname@example.org.Read the full report
The United Arab Emirates (“UAE”) and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (“KSA”) have announced that VAT will be implemented on 1 January 2018. This effective date has been confirmed by the final VAT laws, which have now been published by both the UAE and KSA. The other GCC countries have yet to make an official announcement on the implementation date.
At the time of writing, of the GCC countries, KSA has published its final VAT law and implementing regulations and UAE has only published its final VAT law.
Overview of VAT in the GCC
VAT registered businesses that supply goods and services are subject to VAT at either the standard rate or zero rate. Businesses are entitled to claim a credit for VAT paid on their purchases if they relate to a supply that is standard rated or zero rated. However, any VAT incurred in connection with a supply that is exempt from VAT cannot be reclaimed.
Unless supplies of goods or services are specifically zero rated or exempt, they will be subject to VAT at the standard rate. The standard rate will be 5% across the GCC.
Education – The GCC VAT Treaty
It is common for many countries across the world to exempt education from VAT.
Under the GCC VAT framework agreement, which is a country level agreement between GCC states setting out the common principles on which VAT laws in individual countries will be based, each GCC country has the discretion to either exempt the education sector from VAT or subject it to VAT at the zero rate.
What we know so far on VAT treatment for Education sector in individual countries?
The UAE VAT law states that VAT applies at the zero rate to the “supply of educational services and related Goods and Services for nurseries, preschool, elementary education, and higher educational institutions owned or funded by Federal or local Government, as specified in the Executive Regulation of this Decree-Law.” An interesting observation is that there is no reference to secondary education so unless the executive regulations bring it within the scope of the zero rate, the supply of education services related to secondary education will be subject to VAT at the standard rate.
According to KSA’s VAT implementing regulations, supplies of education services are not exempt or zero rated. Therefore, the expectation is that the education sector in KSA will generally be subject to VAT at the standard rate. However, services provided by the government as part of its government function are outside the scope of VAT and thus public education providers may not be subject to VAT in KSA where there is no commercial activity.
The other GCC countries have not yet made any announcements on the VAT treatment for the education sector.
Different treatment of education across GCC
As the GCC VAT framework agreement gives individual states the ability to subject education sector to either VAT at the zero rate or treat it as exempt, it is possible that education services may be treated differently in individual GCC countries. Indeed, as noted above, in the UAE certain education services will be zero rated whereas KSA appears to prefer the standard rated approach.
What are the implications if education is exempt?
Clearly there will be implications for education providers in GCC countries where the education sector is exempt because they will not be able to recover any VAT incurred on their expenses directly attributable to that exempt supply.
Education service providers that make both taxable and exempt supplies will also need to apportion the VAT in relation to certain shared overheads – for example, marketing, utilities and rent – because the VAT attributable to exempt supplies will not be recoverable.
These factors will increase the cost for education providers who may, in turn, wish to raise the school fees to compensate for the higher cost in order to maintain profit levels.
What are the implications if education is zero rated?
A consequence of zero rated treatment is that the educational provider is likely to be in a VAT refund position, which may result in cash flow issues. Therefore, it is important for affected businesses to manage and review their commercial contracts, invoices and VAT refund claims to reduce this impact.
What is the definition of education?
The meaning of “education” services where such services are either exempt or zero rated is important because ultimately this will dictate the VAT treatment. To the extent that any services fall outside the definition of “education”, they will be subject to VAT at the standard rate. Any potential exclusions from the zero rated or exempt treatment must also be considered.
In the UAE, certain education services will be zero rated, but it is remains to be seen how “education” and “education provider” will be defined for these purposes and whether there will be any exclusions from the zero rated treatment. In some countries, the definition of “education” is usually based on local law and subject to the education provider being accredited by the local educational authority.
The VAT treatment can vary depending on whether the education provider is engaged in pre-school, primary, secondary or higher education. Some countries also appear to favour a distinction between private and public sector education providers with the latter not subject to VAT.
In addition to education services, for which the education provider usually charges a school or tuition fee, the education provider may also be engaged in other ancillary services. Determining the VAT treatment may present challenges for such services. For example, education providers may also undertake the following income generating activities:
It is important to determine whether and to what extent the above activities will fall to be treated as related and incidental to “education” services and subject to the same VAT treatment, or whether they will be considered as supplies of a different service and subject to separate VAT treatment.
Businesses must ensure that appropriate controls and processes are in place and that the correct VAT classification is identified for all your transactions at the outset in order to be compliant and avoid penalties.
Al Tamimi & Company’s tax team regularly advises on VAT implementation. For further information please contact Shiraz Khan (email@example.com).