This issue is filled with great insights and expert commentary on areas that are relevant to the legal landscape and highlight how the business community is embracing technology, media and telecommunications. There are various topics covered, from new ways of working and digital transformation in the finance sector to data protection regulatory updates and guidance. We also have a series of articles that focus on e-commerce across a number of jurisdictions.
You will also find insights from our lawyers around real estate analytics, tech trends, and data centres.
We hope this edition of Law Update provides some useful food for thought – enjoy the read!Take a read of the edition
The purpose of this article is to provide a general overview of the establishment of the Economic Cities (ECs) under the authority of the Saudi Arabian General Investment Authority (SAGIA) and information on key issues including land ownership and employment issues. The article also discusses implications of ECs and the specific incentives offered by SAGIA and the establishment of business operations in ECs.
For reasons that will become clear below, we note that many areas of the applicable regulations to ECs are uncertain, evolving or subject to change.
ECs sites and objectives
The following are the ECs that are at the development stage:
SAGIA status and authority
SAGIA was created under the Foreign Investment Act (FIA) in April 2000. The FIA significantly amended the foreign investment framework in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA).
SAGIA issues licenses to foreign investors for foreign capital investment in permitted business activity in KSA, whether permanent or temporary.
Pursuant to a recommendation of the Supreme Economic Council in June 2006, by a decision of the Council of Ministers, SAGIA was specifically granted the responsibility for all activities relating to the ECs.
Before this date SAGIA was already active in the promotion of the ECs. For example, in November 2005, SAGIA entered into an agreement with Emaar Properties, under which it agreed to take certain actions to facilitate the development of KAEC. Further, with respect to PABMEC in May 2006, SAGIA signed an agreement with a regional investment holding company for the development of the project.
Generally, based on the above, SAGIA has the authority to issue licenses for the development of the ECs. The license issued by SAGIA allows the Master Developer (MD) to establish and carry out investment projects in connection with the relevant EC. SAGIA license includes the cost of the project. A MD will usually establish a Project Company (PC) to undertake the development of an EC.
The authority of SAGIA regarding ECs appears to be implicitly recognized under Saudi law. We are not aware of the publication by SAGIA of any special act or regulations applicable to the special ECs in KSA. However, we have been informed that the Economic Cities Agency at SAGIA has finalized the draft of the Economic Cities Act and legal code but has not approved it or disclosed it yet.
Land Ownership and Development in ECs
Rights and Obligations of SAGIA and License holder
The rights and obligations of the parties (SAGIA and MD) are covered in contractual arrangements for development. In principle, MD will enter into a Master Developer Agreement (Agreement) with SAGIA. Key obligations of a MD include the development and operation of EC and committing-on behalf of PC (under formation) – to undertake an initial public offering. As part of the private sector participation in KSA’s economic growth the PC will be required to offer 30% of its issued share capital to the retail.
Under the Agreement, SAGIA generally assumes certain obligations with respect to the facilitation of EC project’s development, conferring any special status on EC required for the project, and facilitating governmental and other approvals and other required actions. SAGIA will, for example, commit to facilitate (a) the registration of all foreign owned companies and other entities established in the ECs, (b) the registration of all land title deeds in the name of foreign entities established in ECs and (c) the issuance of licenses and other regulatory approvals allowing for industrial land usage within the ECs, including district cooling, warehousing, logistics and industrial park distribution …etc.
Project Land Ownership in ECs
Generally, the following chain of ownership structure has been used in some of the ECs by SAGIA: the land for the EC is acquired by the MD -chosen by SAGIA- from a governmental entity, local authority or other party that owns the land. The terms of such acquisition may vary on a case-by-case basis, for example, as to price. The MD will then transfer title to the land to the PC, for example, by an in-kind contribution on its formation. The PC will in turn transfer the land to investors under a long-term lease or develop the land for sale to third parties or retain ownership of the land and manage the developed property or enter into strategic partnerships, alliances or joint ventures for the development of components of the EC.
Similar model was contemplated by SAGIA for the MD of KAEC and PABMEC.
Note that under Royal Decree number M/15 dated 11/03/1424 (H.) corresponding to 13/05/2003 (G.), ministries, governmental agencies and other authorities (including SAGIA) may appropriate real estate for public interest purposes, subject to fair compensation being paid and such acquisition being for a project expressly contemplated in the government budget. Therefore, the land may remain in the ownership of the SAGIA but be managed by MD. In such case, there should be a clear agreement between MD and the SAGIA giving PC the ability to convey title/ownership rights to third party purchasers.
Rights of property ownership
Real estate ownership in KSA for companies and individuals which are non GCC /Saudi nationals is mainly covered by the Foreign Investment Law and the Law of Non-Saudis Proprietorship and Investment of Real Estate issued by the Royal Decree 15 dated 17/4/1421H (Foreign R/E Ownership Law).
With regard to GCC Nationals Royal Decree No 4 dated 12/7/1415/H and Executive Rules (GCC R/E Ownership Law).
One of the issues is that foreign ownership of KSA property must be linked to a particular project and is not a general right.
The GCC ownership law provides that GCC nationals can own real estate in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (“KSA”) in the following circumstances:
The Non–Saudi Proprietorship Law entitles foreign investors to own real estate in KSA which is required for:
Even the smallest minority interest held by a non-GCC (or foreign) national will be sufficient to make a corporate entity “foreign”, thus triggering the requirement for a SAGIA license.
At this stage, instead of designating areas for possible foreign ownership in the nature of free zone jurisdictions and investment zones, KSA has left the licensing of sites to the discretion of SAGIA and simply stipulated two areas where there is a prohibition on foreigners acquiring real estate, namely land within the city limits of Mecca and Al Medina Al Munawara.
Property lease/ownership and deed formalities
In terms of real estate ownership in ECs, 100% foreign landownership is allowed in the ECs except for KEC-in Al Medina Al Munawara. Once the investor has completed all commercial agreements with the EC developers regarding land lease and/or ownerships, the Smart Service Center (SSC) will facilitate the official property lease/ownership and deed formalities required.
Documentation requirements include the following:
With respect to the ECs and employment matters, SAGIA offers a one-stop shop/fast track government immigration centre for ECs to deal with prompt approval and processing of visas, easing of application of labour law requirements, overseas recruitment and renewal of visa and work permits. Since the development of an EC is considered a private project, employing Saudi citizens will be required .
The amount of information available from SAGIA on this subject is very limited.
However, we note that in the ECs, a more liberal regime will apply to employment issues than in the normal Saudi environment. However, Saudization requirements would still apply in ECs.
Further incentives offered by SAGIA:
SAGIA offers the following incentives to investors in ECs:
Foreign investment restrictions in the ECs:
An understanding of foreign investment restrictions in ECs requires some background on the applicable foreign investment framework in Saudi Arabia. See generally the creation of SAGIA under the FIA discussed above.
A negative list has been issued by SAGIA for some business activities that are prohibited to foreign investment. These include manufacture of military materials, equipment and explosives, oil exploration and production, services related to security, real estate brokerage, and land transportation services (excluding trains), among others. The Kingdom is currently reducing the sectors that are not open to foreign investors: retailing, telecommunications and insurance have already been removed from the list.
In a change from the previous investment law, the FIA allows foreigners 100% ownership of certain projects, as well as property required for the project itself or for housing company personnel (with the exception of real estate in Mecca and Al Medina Al Munawara-see above). Under this scheme, foreign investors are allowed to retain the same incentives, privileges and guarantees given to national companies other than taxation.
For example, projects that are 100% foreign-owned are eligible for loans from the Saudi Industrial Development Fund. Investors are also able to hold investment licenses in more than one type of activity. The law has also brought significant changes to the previous sponsorship regulations. Under the new scheme, foreign investors and their non-Saudi employees may be sponsored under a new licensed firm.
Foreign investments are protected by law and may not be confiscated wholly or partially without a court order. Moreover, such investments may not be subject to expropriation wholly or partially except in the public interest in return for equitable compensation.
SAGIA will provide all Government services through its Smart Service Center (SSC) operations. SAGIA is in the process of establishing SSC centers within the ECs offering enhanced services to investors, until the EC SSC centers are completed, all investors wishing to establish in the ECs will be serviced (60/24/7) through existing SSC’s located in all major cities within KSA. The SSC currently offers more than 128 government services and is continuously enhancing its basket services. SSC ensures a fast-track and hassle-free process for establishing a company in ECs.
Foreign investments – general
Generally, a license will be required from SAGIA for any such investment.
The conditions for SAGIA granting a foreign investment license include the following:
Most of the above conditions are fulfilled by foreign investors relatively easily.
Foreign investors are also required to submit a declaration stating non-availability of a residency permit in KSA over the last two years. In cases where the investor has held a residency permit in KSA, a letter approved by the last investor’s sponsor must be submitted stating the sponsor’s non-objection to the return of the investor to KSA for the purpose of investment.
Corporate structures in use in ECs
An investor may choose one of several forms of business when establishing business operations in the ECs. The following are the common legal forms used in ECs:
Establishment process- Step by Step- at SSC
The establishment of an investment vehicle in the ECs in whatever form will inevitably involve a number of common steps, including:
Step 1. Obtain an investment license from SAGIA;
Step 2. Approval of the entity’s trade name and location ;
Step 3 Obtaining Labor Office File Number (File 700);
Step 4. Resident Manager: Obtain Residency Permit/Iqama;
Step 5. Physical premises: Obtain Property Ownership Deed/Lease contract;
Step 6. Approval of draft articles of association (or a Ministerial resolution for a branch);
Step 7. Notarizing and Publishing the articles of association (Companies only);
Step 8. Depositing the entity’s paid-up capital in a local bank and issuing bank certificate;
Step 9. Commercial Registration from the Ministry of Commerce;
Step 10. Chamber of commerce and industry membership registration;
Step 11. Labour Office registration;
Step 12. Tax registration;
Step 13. Registering employer and employees for the General Organisation of Social Insurance (GOSI) contributions; and
Step 14. possibly, the role of specialised authorities/agencies such CITC or Ministry of Information.
The above entire process is serviced on a fast-track basis through SSC.
Al Tamimi & Company’s KSA office is focusing on setting up foreign companies in Special Economic Cities and is currently providing legal assistance for the Master Developer of King Abdullah Financial District (KAFD).
Our KSA office is involved in the revision of all rules and instructions regulating the KAFD and most agreements and contracts between MD and other developers, contractors and companies intended on having a presence in the KAFD, such as banks and financial institutions.